Does Whirlwind bypass Ruin Runner's 'can't be chosen' protection since it doesn't target?

verified
FAQ #1000·asked by 470650214202605578·December 31, 2025·Rules v1.4·Asked before Vendetta
Answer

Ruling: Yes, Whirlwind can return Ruin Runner to hand because Whirlwind doesn't target. Ruin Runner's "can't be chosen" means "can't be targeted" in card templating, and Whirlwind bypasses this protection.

Sequence:

  • Whirlwind resolves
  • Each player chooses a unit they control to return to hand
  • The player controlling Ruin Runner can choose it because the choice is not targeting

Nuances:

  • Whirlwind doesn't target because multiple players are making the choice (the set of objects is chosen in part by other players)
  • "Choose" in card templating generally means "target", but Whirlwind is an exception due to multiple players participating in the choice
  • This same principle applies to other cards like Cull the Weak, Divine Judgement, Downwell, Imperial Decree, and King's Edict
  • Reflexive triggers (like from Falling Star) still target and cannot affect Ruin Runner

Does this answer look correct?

0
Comments (0)

No comments yet.

Log in to comment.

Open Proposals (0)

No pending proposals.

Log in to propose edits.