0

Do you still kill your own unit if your opponent counters your "Sacrifice" with "Defy"?

verified
FAQ #10480·May 19, 2026·Asked before Vendetta
Answer

Yes, you still kill your own unit.

According to Rule 357 and RiftJudge FAQ #9906, the process of playing a spell includes paying its costs before the spell is added to the chain and becomes eligible to be countered.

The Sequence:

  1. Announcement: You announce you are playing Sacrifice.
  2. Payment of Costs: You pay the energy cost and the additional cost (killing a friendly Mighty unit). This happens instantly when you play the card.
  3. Finalization: Only after the unit is killed and sent to the trash is Sacrifice finalized and placed on the chain.
  4. Reaction: Your opponent receives priority and plays Defy to counter Sacrifice.

The Result:

Because the unit was already killed as a cost to play the spell, it is already in the trash by the time Defy is even played. Rule 425.1.c confirms that countering a card does not refund any costs paid to play it, including additional costs. Your unit remains in the trash, and your Sacrifice is removed from the chain.

Comments (0)

No comments yet.

Log in to comment.

Open Proposals (0)

No pending proposals.

Log in to propose edits.