If you star crossed out of a showdown is it considered a combat?
No, playing Star-Crossed does not determine whether a situation is a "combat"—the existence of combat is determined by the units present at the battlefield, not by the spells played.
Here is the breakdown of how this works:
1. What determines Combat?
According to Rule 454 and Rule 456, a combat exists at a battlefield if units controlled by opposing players are present there.
- If you play Star-Crossed during a showdown, it simply removes units from the board.
- If removing those units leaves only one player's units (or no units) at the battlefield, the battlefield may stop being "contested," but it does not retroactively change the fact that a combat was staged there, nor does the act of playing Star-Crossed itself change the nature of the showdown.
2. Does Star-Crossed end a Showdown?
No. According to RiftJudge FAQ #7670, a showdown does not end just because units are moved off the battlefield. The showdown continues until all players pass focus in a row.
3. The Sequence
If you play Star-Crossed during a showdown:
- Chain: Star-Crossed is added to the chain.
- Resolution: Star-Crossed resolves, returning the target units to hand.
- State: The showdown remains ongoing (Rule 348).
- Combat Status:
- If, after the units are returned to hand, there are still units from both players at the battlefield, it remains a Combat Showdown.
- If the units returned by Star-Crossed were the only units representing one or both sides of the combat, the combat is no longer "staged" with opposing units. However, because a showdown only ends when players pass focus, the players continue to have the opportunity to play spells until they both pass.
In summary: Playing Star-Crossed is a reaction that affects the board state during a showdown, but it does not "create" or "cancel" a combat definition—it only alters the presence of the units that are currently defining that status.
Does this answer look correct?
No comments yet.
Log in to comment.
No pending proposals.
Log in to propose edits.