1

if I play hostile takeover as my first card to gain control of Astral Heron at a battlefield do I get to use it's effect to make my second card cheaper?

unverified
FAQ #11938·asked by Peeky·August 23, 2026
Answer

Sign in as an arbiter with more than 50 reputation to verify answers. Learn more →

No. Astral Heron's trigger condition is evaluated the moment your first card is played — and at that moment you don't control Heron yet, so the ability can't fire for you.

Hostile Takeover only resolves after you've already played your first card, so gaining control of Heron afterward doesn't retroactively create the discount. The "when you play your first card" trigger looks at who controls Heron when that card is played (Rule 383.2.a.1, 383.2.c), not after. Same principle as the ruling that playing your first card while Heron is at Base, then moving him to a battlefield, doesn't give you the discount — the condition check has already passed.

Note the errata'd text: "the next card you play this turn" — even if you did control Heron, the discount would only apply to a card played after the trigger resolves, and it would expire at end of turn.

Related Cards

Comments (0)

No comments yet.

Log in to comment.

Open Proposals (1)
Flubjub·August 23, 2026

Wrong ruling.

Yes. You take control of Heron during resolution of the spell. When Hostile Takeover finishes resolving Astral Heron will trigger and grant you the discount on the next card. But Hostile Takeover has to be your first card played that turn.

Log in to propose edits.