My opponent has Hwei on base and plays a Tide Turner on base. Declines to move anything. Does a trigger still occur that creates a chain I can react to?

verified
FAQ #11991·August 3, 2026
Answer

No. Tideturner's "you may" is decided during finalization — if its controller declines, the ability is removed from the chain and never becomes a Finalized Chain Item, so no chain exists and you get no reaction window.

This follows (a "you may" that leads the effect decides whether the ability is performed at all; declining means it "is removed from the chain and considered to have not triggered"). It also doesn't matter that Hwei is at Base: "another location" excludes Base, so there was no legal swap target anyway (). Note that even when the trigger is performed, you couldn't react to Tideturner entering play itself — you can only react to the play-effect chain that follows (FAQ #6244).

Does this answer look correct?

0
Comments (0)

No comments yet.

Log in to comment.

Open Proposals (0)

No pending proposals.

Log in to propose edits.