When you play Temporal Breach on a battlefield you control, does it start a showdown?
No — if the unit's owner already controls the battlefield, no showdown starts.
Temporal Breach banishes a unit and its owner plays it back to the same location. Contested is only applied when a unit becomes present at a battlefield its controller doesn't already control (Rule 190.3.a.1). Replaying your own unit to a battlefield you control doesn't satisfy that, so nothing is staged (matches FAQ #8066 — playing a unit to a battlefield you control never triggers a showdown).
One caveat: if you target an opponent's unit sitting on a battlefield you control, the opponent plays their unit back to a battlefield they don't control — that applies Contested and a showdown (combat or non-combat, depending on who else has units there) will be staged in the next cleanup.
Does this answer look correct?
No comments yet.
Log in to comment.
No pending proposals.
Log in to propose edits.