My opponent uses Imperial Decree which resolves, then moves to my battlefield where Akali Silent sits with Guardian Angel attached, opens showdown with Bellows breath x2 which I have no reaction to so we move to resolve. How would this resolve?
Sign in as an arbiter with more than 50 reputation to verify answers. Learn more →
Yes — Akali dies. Guardian Angel only saves her from the first kill trigger; the second Imperial Decree trigger will find and kill her even after she's recalled to base.
Sequence: Bellows Breath (with Repeat) resolves as two separate 1-damage instances, and each instance triggers Imperial Decree's "When any unit takes damage this turn, kill it" — so two kill triggers go on the chain. The first trigger resolves: Guardian Angel's replacement effect kicks in, destroying itself, and Akali is healed, exhausted, and recalled to base. The second trigger then resolves and kills her at base, since Imperial Decree's trigger tracks the unit regardless of location (FAQ #8761/#9419).
Two notes: Akali's "can't be chosen unless I'm in combat" doesn't save her — during the Combat Showdown she has the Defender designation and is in combat, so she's a legal target for Bellows Breath, and Imperial Decree's kill trigger doesn't "choose" her anyway. Also, if "x2" meant two separate Bellows Breath casts rather than Repeat, the result is the same: GA is consumed on the first kill, and the second Bellows Breath's damage triggers a fresh kill.
References
Suggested answer — derived from the references below
Rules
Related FAQs
Related Cards
So I guess the question is, even though it’s legal to target her at the time of use, if during combat resolve conditions change, can that retro-actively nullify the target since there is no longer a valid target? ie... Akali silent cannot be targeted if not in combat. This one is hurting my brain.
Log in to comment.
No pending proposals.
Log in to propose edits.