if i use Shuriken Flip on my mournful witness at my base. and target a 2 might poro at a battlefield. it kills the poro and moves my unit. does a combat showdown still occur or is the poro dead before it moves so its a non combat?
Sign in as an arbiter with more than 50 reputation to verify answers. Learn more →
No — this is a non-combat showdown, not a combat showdown.
Here's why: Shuriken Flip's damage and move both resolve inside one chain item, so at the moment the Witness moves, the Poro only has lethal damage marked — it isn't actually dead yet. The battlefield becomes Contested (Rule 445/450), but death and Combat staging don't happen until the cleanup after the chain resolves (Rule 453). During that cleanup the Poro is killed (Rule 323.5), so when the game checks Rule 323.9, there are no units of two opposing players at the battlefield — only your Witness. Only a Showdown gets staged (Rule 323.8), and when the turn player initiates it, it opens as a non-combat showdown (FAQ #11630).
Practical result: no Attacker/Defender designations, no "when I attack" triggers, no Combat Cleanup healing, and your Witness conquers the battlefield when the showdown closes since you're the only player with units there (Rule 348.2.a).
References
Suggested answer — derived from the references below
Rules
Related FAQs
Related Cards
No comments yet.
Log in to comment.
No pending proposals.
Log in to propose edits.