Can you cast repulse without a spell target, just with a creature target? Just to get a ''when you play a spell effect''?

verified
FAQ #12384·asked by Crabdre·August 30, 2026
Answer

No. Repulse requires both targets — a friendly unit at a battlefield and an enemy spell or ability on the chain that chooses that unit and no other friendly unit. The counter instruction is mandatory, not optional ("Counter..." with no "up to" or "may").

Without a qualifying enemy spell/ability on the chain, Repulse fails the check at finalization that the card made appropriate choices, since its targets aren't legal (), and can't be played at all — even just to trigger "when you play a spell" effects. This matches the ruling for Riposte ("Choose a friendly unit and a spell"): every choice in the list is a mandatory target, and all must be legal before the spell can go on the chain.

References

Suggested answer — derived from the references below

Rules

Core Rules 2026-07-16 > Section 300: Playing the Game > Rule 359.3

Core Rules 2026-07-16 > Section 700: Additional Rules > Rule 758

Related Cards

Does this answer look correct?

0
Correction History (1)

October 13, 2026 · reviewed by 243326460528427008

Rules update

The ruling still holds (a spell with unmet target requirements can't be played), but it cites 358.1 as checking that all targets are legal, and the new text says it checks that the card made appropriate choices (targets legal, requirements met per rule 355), so the citation and reasoning need rewording.

**No.** Repulse requires *both* targets — a friendly unit at a battlefield **and** an enemy spell or ability on the chain that chooses that unit and no other friendly unit. The counter instruction is mandatory, not optional ("Counter..." with no "up to" or "may"). Without a qualifying enemy spell/ability on the chain, Repulse fails the check at finalization that the card made appropriate choices, since its targets aren't legal (Rule 358.1), and can't be played at all — even just to trigger "when you play a spell" effects. This matches the ruling for Riposte ("Choose a friendly unit and a spell"): every choice in the list is a mandatory target, and all must be legal before the spell can go on the chain.

Comments (0)

No comments yet.

Log in to comment.

Open Proposals (0)

No pending proposals.

Log in to propose edits.