Can I react to shens “when I hold with one other unit I score” or any passive type abilities
Sign in as an arbiter with more than 50 reputation to verify answers. Learn more →
Yes for Shen's hold ability — no for genuine passive abilities.
Shen, Leader of the Kinkou Order reads "[Shield] When I hold, if there is exactly one other unit you control here, you score 1 point." The "when I hold" clause makes this a Hold Effect, i.e. a triggered ability, so it's put on the chain as a pending item and every player gets a Reaction window before it resolves (Rule 383.4.d). What you can't react to is the hold/score event that caused it.
One nuance: the "exactly one other unit you control here" clause sits immediately after the trigger condition, so it's part of the condition, not the effect (Rule 383.2.a.1) — it's checked when the trigger fires, and killing that other unit in response won't stop the point. Once the trigger is on the chain it resolves.
Passive abilities are different: they're statements of fact with no "when/at" condition (Shield is a passive, for example), they never use the chain, and there is no priority window in which to react to them — they just continuously apply.
References
Suggested answer — derived from the references below
Rules
Related Cards
No comments yet.
Log in to comment.
No pending proposals.
Log in to propose edits.