0

When a spell played with flow is countered, does it get banished instead of going to the trash?

verified
FAQ #12607·asked by Schnitsel·September 17, 2026
Answer

Yes — a spell played for its Flow cost gets banished when it's countered, not trashed.

Flow's "then banish it" is a delayed replacement effect: if the spell would leave the chain after becoming a finalized chain item and the departure wasn't instructed by its own execution, it's banished instead (Rule 829.1.b.1). Being countered is exactly that kind of departure, so the trash destination is replaced by banishment — this is an explicit exception to the normal countered-spell rule (Rule 425.1.a.1). The same holds if the counter effect would otherwise return it to hand, e.g. Abandon (FAQ #11738).

Note the distinction: this only applies to the Flow play. A copy of that same spell played from hand for its normal cost and countered just goes to the trash.

References

Suggested answer — derived from the references below

Rules

CR 829

Core Rules 2026-07-16 > Section 800: Keywords > Rule 829

CR 425

Core Rules 2026-07-16 > Section 400: Section 400 > Rule 425

CR 156

Core Rules 2026-07-16 > Section 100: Game Concepts > Rule 156

Comments (1)
settlover_·September 17, 2026

[prod smoke] App API comment — safe to ignore/delete

Log in to comment.

Open Proposals (1)
settlover_·September 17, 2026

production smoke test

[prod smoke] ignore — App API proposal test

829425156

Log in to propose edits.