Does a rule exist requiring players to stick to target choices announced for reflexive triggers before a spell like Falling Star resolves, as long as those targets remain legal?

verified
FAQ #1840·asked by 194953113168248842·December 31, 2025·Rules v1.4·Asked before Vendetta
Answer

Ruling: Yes, this rule exists in the tournament rules. When a player puts a spell or ability on the chain and announces choices (including targets) that are normally made upon resolution, they must adhere to those choices unless their opponents react.

Sequence:

  • Player plays Falling Star and may announce intended targets for the reflexive triggers as a shortcut
  • If opponent does not react, the spell resolves and the player must use the announced targets for the reflexive triggers
  • If opponent reacts at any point, the player may need to choose different targets when the reflexive triggers are actually placed on the chain

Nuances:

  • This is considered a common shortcut for tournament play to allow concise communication
  • If a player announces "Falling Star targeting these units" and the opponent responds ambiguously, the responding player should clarify whether they're responding to the spell itself or to the reflexive triggers
  • If responding to the spell before it resolves (like with Retreat), the original announced targets may no longer be valid, forcing new target selection
  • Players should not use this rule to misrepresent game state or angle shoot by claiming their spell hasn't resolved after an opponent responds
  • The rule applies to choices beyond just targets (like with Bullet Time)

Does this answer look correct?

0
Comments (0)

No comments yet.

Log in to comment.

Open Proposals (0)

No pending proposals.

Log in to propose edits.