0

Does Tideturner cause you to lose control of a battlefield mid-resolution when swapping units, potentially allowing you to contest or score?

verified
FAQ #1887·asked by 183915620134420480·December 31, 2025·Rules v1.4·Asked before Vendetta
Answer

Ruling: You do not lose control of a battlefield during Tideturner's resolution. Control is only checked during cleanups, which occur after the entire effect resolves, not in the middle of it.

Sequence:

  • Tideturner's effect begins resolving as one complete action
  • Both unit moves occur as part of this single resolution (though not truly simultaneously, as game actions cannot be simultaneous)
  • After the entire effect finishes resolving, cleanup occurs
  • Control is checked during this cleanup, not during the resolution

Nuances:

  • Rule 181.4.c states control is lost "immediately" when you have no units at a battlefield, which initially suggested mid-resolution control loss
  • However, rule 322.4 (which handles control during cleanups) is more specific and takes precedence
  • Rule 151.3.a states nothing can be addressed during resolution, including things caused by execution
  • The moves within Tideturner are part of one game action; the move is not "complete" until the ability finishes resolving
  • This only matters in edge cases where another unit at the battlefield is removed in response (via Gust, Retreat, etc.) before Tideturner resolves
Comments (0)

No comments yet.

Log in to comment.

Open Proposals (0)

No pending proposals.

Log in to propose edits.