Can you play Defy with no target to buff Ravenbloom Student (trigger its 'when you play a spell' effect)?
verified
Answer
Ruling: No, you cannot play Defy without a valid target. Spells require a target to be played.
Nuances:
- According to RAW (rules as written), counterspells can technically target themselves because the spell goes on the chain before targets are declared, making itself a valid target
- However, if a counterspell targets itself and gets countered/fizzles, it does not count as played and would not trigger play effects like Ravenbloom Student
- The designer indicated they will likely change the rules to prevent counterspells from targeting themselves in the future
- You could play 2 Defies (first targeting itself, second targeting the first) to actually "play" one spell and trigger Ravenbloom Student, though this is inefficient
Does this answer look correct?
0
Comments (0)
No comments yet.
Log in to comment.
Open Proposals (0)
No pending proposals.
Log in to propose edits.