0
Does Whirlwind trigger Deflect?
verified
Answer
Ruling: Whirlwind does not trigger Deflect because it is not a targeted spell. The units are chosen by players after the spell is cast, not targeted when the spell is played.
Sequence:
- Whirlwind's cost is paid when the spell is cast
- After the spell resolves, players choose units
- Since the choice happens after casting (not during targeting), Deflect's additional cost does not apply
Nuances:
- When card effects refer to "choose" in contexts like Deflect, it actually means "target"
- Rule 352.10.e specifies that objects chosen in whole or in part by other players are not targets
- Deflect is an additional cost paid when playing a spell, so if the choice isn't made when finalizing the spell, Deflect doesn't apply
- Targeting is the only way to choose a unit when finalizing a spell
Comments (0)
No comments yet.
Log in to comment.
Open Proposals (0)
No pending proposals.
Log in to propose edits.