0

Does Tianna Crownguard prevent hold abilities from triggering, or does she only prevent the victory point from being scored?

verified
FAQ #4843·asked by 236520527173255168·January 4, 2026·Rules v1.4·Asked before Vendetta
Answer

Ruling: Tianna Crownguard only prevents the victory point from being scored, but does not prevent hold abilities from triggering. When the act of gaining a point from holding is negated or replaced, the hold effect will still trigger.

Sequence:

  • Player maintains control of a battlefield during their Beginning Phase
  • Player attempts to score a victory point from holding
  • Tianna Crownguard prevents the victory point from being gained
  • Hold abilities still trigger despite the point being prevented

Nuances:

  • This same principle applies to conquer abilities - if you conquer while at 7 points and cannot score the 8th point, you still get the conquer effect
  • Scoring triggers both the point gain and the hold/conquer abilities, but these are independent - preventing one doesn't prevent the other
  • The rules explicitly state that if gaining a point from holding or conquering is negated or replaced in any way, the hold/conquer effect will still trigger
Comments (0)

No comments yet.

Log in to comment.

Open Proposals (0)

No pending proposals.

Log in to propose edits.