0

If Carnivorous Snapvine targets a Travelling Merchant on the battlefield, but the Merchant gets Flashed back to base before Snapvine resolves, does Snapvine still kill it?

verified
FAQ #4962·asked by 513458417470537728·January 4, 2026·Rules v1.4·Asked before Vendetta
Answer

Ruling: No, Snapvine does not kill the Merchant. Since Snapvine specifies "battlefield" and the Merchant is no longer on the battlefield when the spell resolves, it is not a valid target and the spell does nothing.

Sequence:

  • Carnivorous Snapvine is cast and targets Travelling Merchant on the battlefield
  • Merchant is Flashed back to base in response
  • Snapvine resolves, but Merchant is no longer on the battlefield
  • Snapvine does nothing because the target is not in the valid zone

Nuances:

  • Spells that can target units anywhere (like Challenge, which can target units at bases) would still resolve even if the unit moves zones
  • If a unit gains Deflect after costs are paid but before resolution, the caster does not need to pay additional costs because costs have already been calculated and paid
Comments (0)

No comments yet.

Log in to comment.

Open Proposals (0)

No pending proposals.

Log in to propose edits.