0

If Zhonya is played as a hidden card at battlefield 1, then activated as a reaction to Charm moving the only unit away from that battlefield, does Zhonya remain in play even though there are no units left at battlefield 1?

verified
FAQ #5142·asked by 261595992065966080·January 4, 2026·Rules v1.4·Asked before Vendetta
Answer

Ruling: Yes, Zhonya remains in play as a gear waiting for the first unit to be killed, even though there are no units at the battlefield where it was originally hidden.

Sequence:

  • Zhonya is hidden at battlefield 1 with one unit present
  • Opponent plays Charm to move the unit from battlefield 1 to battlefield 2
  • A chain opens and you react by playing Zhonya from hidden
  • Zhonya (as a gear) goes to base waiting for the first unit to be killed
  • The chain ends
  • Charm resolves
  • No units remain at battlefield 1, but Zhonya is still in play

Nuances:

  • Zhonya does not target, so it can save a unit at any battlefield regardless of where it was originally hidden
  • The "here" restriction on hidden cards is a targeting restriction that only applies to effects that target
  • Effects that don't target aren't restricted by the location where the hidden card was played
Comments (0)

No comments yet.

Log in to comment.

Open Proposals (0)

No pending proposals.

Log in to propose edits.