If Zhonya is played as a hidden card at battlefield 1, then activated as a reaction to Charm moving the only unit away from that battlefield, does Zhonya remain in play even though there are no units left at battlefield 1?

verified
FAQ #5142·asked by 261595992065966080·January 4, 2026·Rules v1.4·Asked before Vendetta
Answer

Ruling: Yes, Zhonya remains in play as a gear waiting for the first unit to be killed, even though there are no units at the battlefield where it was originally hidden.

Sequence:

  • Zhonya is hidden at battlefield 1 with one unit present
  • Opponent plays Charm to move the unit from battlefield 1 to battlefield 2
  • A chain opens and you react by playing Zhonya from hidden
  • Zhonya (as a gear) goes to base waiting for the first unit to be killed
  • The chain ends
  • Charm resolves
  • No units remain at battlefield 1, but Zhonya is still in play

Nuances:

  • Zhonya does not target, so it can save a unit at any battlefield regardless of where it was originally hidden
  • The "here" restriction on hidden cards is a targeting restriction that only applies to effects that target
  • Effects that don't target aren't restricted by the location where the hidden card was played

Does this answer look correct?

0
Comments (0)

No comments yet.

Log in to comment.

Open Proposals (0)

No pending proposals.

Log in to propose edits.