When a player accidentally sees an extra card while drawing, what is the remedy? Should recycled cards be separated before shuffling the extra card back?

Ruling: The player receives a warning and shuffles the extra card back into the random portion of the deck (not including recycled or mulligan cards). If this is the third warning of the same type, it escalates to a Game Loss.

Sequence:

• Separate any recycled and mulligan cards from the deck
• Shuffle the extra card into the random portion of the deck
• Issue a warning (or Game Loss if it's the third offense)

Nuances:

• If a player doesn't remember how much they've recycled, attempt to determine it based on the current game state