0
If a card deals X damage to a card at the battlefield, but I chain a card that moves it from the battlefield, would that damage still apply?
verified
Answer
Ruling: No, the damage does not apply if the unit is moved from the battlefield before the damage resolves. When a spell targets a unit at a specific location, that unit must be at that location both when targeted and when the effect resolves.
Sequence:
- The spell targets a unit at a specific location (the battlefield)
- If the unit is not at a valid location when targeting, the spell does not enter the chain
- On resolution, if the target is no longer valid (moved from the battlefield), the "do as much as you can" rule applies
- The damage does not occur because the unit is no longer at the required location
Nuances:
- If the effect depends on the location of another unit (like "here"), moving either unit involved would prevent the effect from happening
- Some spells like Hextech Ray target the unit itself rather than the battlefield location, and will deal damage as long as the unit is at any battlefield when it resolves
Comments (0)
No comments yet.
Log in to comment.
Open Proposals (0)
No pending proposals.
Log in to propose edits.