0
If all defending units die in combat and one has Deathknell, can the defender reveal their hidden unit in response to the Deathknell trigger before losing control of the battlefield?
verified
Answer
Ruling: This is an unresolved rules ambiguity in CRD 1.1 with no official answer. A head judge would need to decide between multiple interpretations.
Possible Rulings:
- Option 1 (RAW): The defender can reveal the hidden unit in response to Deathknell since they still control the battlefield at that moment, potentially leading to a second combat
- Option 2 (RAI): The battlefield's contested status should be removed during cleanup before Deathknell triggers, meaning the hidden card is already discarded and cannot be played
- Option 3: Playing the hidden unit would create an illegal game state (two players controlling the same battlefield simultaneously), so the unit cannot be played
Nuances:
- This ambiguity only exists under CRD 1.1 rules; prior versions handled this differently
- The issue stems from new rules about maintaining control while a battlefield is contested
- Attacker recall would not happen again regardless, as that step has already passed when Deathknell triggers
- No major tournaments have occurred under CRD 1.1 to establish precedent
Comments (0)
No comments yet.
Log in to comment.
Open Proposals (0)
No pending proposals.
Log in to propose edits.