0
If you play Retreat after an opponent targets your unit with Hidden Blade, does the Hidden Blade controller still draw 2 cards?
verified
Answer
Ruling: No, the Hidden Blade controller does not draw 2 cards. When Hidden Blade resolves without a valid target, it cannot determine "its controller" to give them the draw.
Sequence:
- Hidden Blade is played targeting a unit
- Retreat is played in response, returning the unit to hand
- Retreat resolves first, removing the unit from the battlefield
- Hidden Blade attempts to resolve but has no valid target
- Since there is no valid target, "its controller" cannot be determined
- No cards are drawn
Nuances:
- If the unit is moved to base (instead of hand) before Hidden Blade resolves, it also becomes an invalid target and no draw occurs
- If the unit's death is replaced (like with Zhonya's) but it stays at the battlefield, it remains a valid target and the controller still draws 2
- The key distinction is whether Hidden Blade has a valid target at resolution - it needs to be able to reference "its controller" which requires a valid target
- Moving a unit with Flash has the same effect as Retreat - no valid target means no draw
- Targeting in Riftbound is implicit and doesn't require the word "target" to appear on the card
Comments (0)
No comments yet.
Log in to comment.
Open Proposals (0)
No pending proposals.
Log in to propose edits.