0
Are players required to verbally declare when they score points, and should a player be allowed to take back a pass action if they were mistaken about the opponent's point total?
verified
Answer
Ruling: Players must verbally announce when they score points as it is a change to public information. A player cannot take back a pass action once made, even if they were mistaken about the game state. However, obfuscating public information (like hiding a point tracker behind a deck box and not announcing point changes) is a violation of tournament rules.
Sequence:
- Players must announce point changes whenever they hold/conquer a battlefield
- Players must answer truthfully when asked how many points they have
- Players should track points with pen and paper for accuracy
- Once a player passes, they cannot take back that decision
Nuances:
- Writing down points without verbally declaring them when scoring is not sufficient
- Hiding point trackers behind deck boxes while not announcing changes is unsportsmanlike and violates tournament rules about obfuscating public information
- If a player lies about or conceals point totals, they are presenting a dishonest board state
Comments (1)
Rq barcelona final ruling against this. Kokolopez was allowed to go back to previous card played before his mistaken pass.
Log in to comment.
Open Proposals (0)
No pending proposals.
Log in to propose edits.