0
Can you play a hidden Zhonya's from a battlefield in response to a Deathkneel trigger during combat cleanup to save a different unit, and what happens to the Zhonya's?
verified
Answer
Ruling: There is no clear window to play Zhonya's from hidden during combat cleanup. According to the rules, no Focus or Priority is passed during a cleanup (320.1), which would prevent playing the hidden Zhonya's in response to a Deathkneel trigger. However, there is debate about whether priority is gained between the Special Cleanup and the "clear contested status" step (440.1.b) of Combat Cleanup.
Sequence:
- Unit dies during combat, triggering Deathkneel
- Special Cleanup occurs (which includes regular Cleanup procedures)
- During Cleanup, all gear at battlefields is recalled to base (322.5)
- Hidden cards at battlefields not controlled by the same player are removed to trash
- Contested status is cleared (440.1.b)
Nuances:
- Some interpret the rules to allow priority after Special Cleanup but before clearing contested status (312.2.c), which would allow playing Zhonya's while the battlefield is still contested
- This interpretation is disputed and likely not the intended interaction
- Hidden units must be played to their battlefield, but gear (including Zhonya's) is always played to base regardless of where it was hidden
- The question has been submitted for official clarification but no response has been received yet
Comments (0)
No comments yet.
Log in to comment.
Open Proposals (0)
No pending proposals.
Log in to propose edits.