Can you play a hidden Zhonya's from a battlefield in response to a Deathkneel trigger during combat cleanup to save a different unit, and what happens to the Zhonya's?
verified
Answer
Ruling: There is no clear window to play Zhonya's from hidden during combat cleanup. According to the rules, no Focus or Priority is passed during a cleanup (320.1), which would prevent playing the hidden Zhonya's in response to a Deathkneel trigger. However, there is debate about whether priority is gained between the Special Cleanup and the "clear contested status" step (440.1.b) of Combat Cleanup.
Sequence:
- Unit dies during combat, triggering Deathkneel
- Special Cleanup occurs (which includes regular Cleanup procedures)
- During Cleanup, all gear at battlefields is recalled to base (322.5)
- Hidden cards at battlefields not controlled by the same player are removed to trash
- Contested status is cleared (440.1.b)
Nuances:
- Some interpret the rules to allow priority after Special Cleanup but before clearing contested status (312.2.c), which would allow playing Zhonya's while the battlefield is still contested
- This interpretation is disputed and likely not the intended interaction
- Hidden units must be played to their battlefield, but gear (including Zhonya's) is always played to base regardless of where it was hidden
- The question has been submitted for official clarification but no response has been received yet
Does this answer look correct?
0
Comments (0)
No comments yet.
Log in to comment.
Open Proposals (0)
No pending proposals.
Log in to propose edits.