0

How do rules 184.3.c (control cannot change while Contested) and 444.2/444.2.a (establishing control and clearing Contested status) interact? Which happens first?

verified
FAQ #769·asked by 335253472981155842·December 18, 2025·Rules v1.4·Asked before Vendetta
Answer

Ruling: Control is checked constantly through the cleanup mechanism. When a battlefield stops being Contested (444.2.a), control is immediately lost if a player has no units there (184.4.c), triggering a cleanup that removes hidden cards before any new actions can be taken.

Sequence:

  • Contested status is cleared (444.2.a)
  • Control is immediately lost if no units remain (184.4.c)
  • Status change triggers cleanup (319.6)
  • Hidden cards are removed during cleanup
  • Control is established by remaining player (444.2)

Nuances:

  • The word "immediately" in 184.4.c and the cleanup step in 322.6 create apparent tension, but cleanup is the mechanism by which "constant" control checking occurs
  • In edge cases where units from both players remain (e.g., deathknell unit dies and reaction speed unit is played), 444.2/444.2.a don't execute because units are controlled by different players
  • The current rules text could be clearer about the ordering, particularly moving "clear Contested" before "establish control" in the resolution sequence
Comments (0)

No comments yet.

Log in to comment.

Open Proposals (0)

No pending proposals.

Log in to propose edits.