0
Why does Hidden Blade fail to draw cards when its target dies before resolution, but Discipline still draws a card when its target dies or is removed?
verified
Answer
Ruling: Hidden Blade fails to draw cards when its target dies because "its controller" cannot be referenced once the target no longer exists. Discipline still draws a card because it uses "draw 1" (referring to the caster) rather than "its controller" (referring to the target).
Nuances:
- The difference is in the card text wording: "draw 1" vs "its controller draws 1"
- When a card refers to "its controller" (meaning the target's controller), it needs the target to exist to determine who draws
- When a card says "draw 1" without reference to the target, the caster draws regardless of whether the target still exists
Comments (0)
No comments yet.
Log in to comment.
Open Proposals (0)
No pending proposals.
Log in to propose edits.