If I enter an empty battlefield and my opponent moves in a unit as a response, who is the attacker and who is the defender?
verified
Answer
Ruling: When you enter an empty battlefield and your opponent responds by moving in a unit, the first showdown must fully resolve first (ending when both players pass with focus on an empty chain). Then a second combat showdown begins with you as the attacker, since you were the one who applied contested status to the battlefield. This is known as a "surprise defence."
Sequence:
- First showdown begins and must fully resolve (both players pass with focus on empty chain)
- First showdown ends without anyone having control since both players have units at the battlefield
- Second combat showdown begins with the original player (who entered empty battlefield) as attacker
- Control is only established after the second showdown ends
Nuances:
- The opponent can score if they win the second combat showdown
- Even though the opponent has a unit there after their response resolves, the first showdown continues as normal since it already began
Does this answer look correct?
0
Comments (0)
No comments yet.
Log in to comment.
Open Proposals (0)
No pending proposals.
Log in to propose edits.