0
Can I play Punch first to save a unit in response if my opponent plays Falling Star?
verified
FAQ #8482·February 28, 2026·Rules v1.4·Asked before Vendetta
Answer
No, you cannot play Punch First in response to Falling Star.
The reason is the difference between [Action] and [Reaction] timing:
- Falling Star is a standard Spell. When it is played, it starts a Chain.
- According to Rule 334.1.a.1 and 334.1.a.2, cards cannot be played during a "Closed State" (when a Chain is active) unless they have the [Reaction] keyword.
- Punch First has the [Action] keyword. Actions can only be played when the Chain is empty (an "Open State").
Because Falling Star is currently on the Chain, the game is in a Closed State. You would only be able to play a card with the [Reaction] tag to save your unit. By the time the Chain empties and you are able to play an [Action] like Punch First, the Falling Star will have already resolved and dealt its damage.
Comments (0)
No comments yet.
Log in to comment.
Open Proposals (0)
No pending proposals.
Log in to propose edits.