Does Wages of Pain make gold if opponent flashes unit back?

verified
FAQ #9528·April 16, 2026·Asked before Vendetta
Answer

Yes, you will still create the Gold gear token even if the target of Wages of Pain becomes invalid (e.g., because your opponent used a reaction to return it to their hand).

The Ruling

According to RiftJudge FAQ #9296 and #9472 regarding Wages of Pain:

"Wages of Pain WILL still give the gold token even if the target becomes illegal. [...] Wages of Pain's gold token generation is a separate instruction after a full stop that doesn't reference target information, so it executes even when the damage cannot be dealt."

This is consistent with , which states that instructions that cannot be followed are ignored, but instructions that do not reference target information are still executed. Because the creation of the Gold gear token is a separate instruction that does not depend on the success of the damage, it proceeds regardless of the target's status.

The Sequence

  1. Playing the Spell: You play Wages of Pain targeting an enemy unit. The target is locked when the spell is placed on the chain.
  2. Reacting: Your opponent plays a reaction (such as a card that returns the unit to their hand) in response.
  3. Resolution (LIFO):
    • The reaction resolves first, returning the unit to its owner's hand.
    • Wages of Pain then attempts to resolve. Because the target is no longer on the battlefield, it is now an illegal target. The instruction to "Deal 3 to a unit" cannot be performed and is ignored.
    • The next instruction, "Play a Gold gear token exhausted," does not reference the target and therefore executes successfully.

Does this answer look correct?

0
Comments (0)

No comments yet.

Log in to comment.

Open Proposals (0)

No pending proposals.

Log in to propose edits.