0

If my unit with Temporary dies during my Beginning Phase and triggers a Deathknell ability, can I play a unit from Deathknell to the now-empty battlefield before it becomes uncontrolled?

verified
FAQ #9618·asked by 243326460528427008·April 19, 2026·Rules v1.4·Asked before Vendetta
Answer

Ruling: Yes. When Temporary triggers during your Beginning Phase, the Deathknell ability is added to the chain as a pending item before the unit moves to the trash. Because a pending item exists on the chain, the game is in a Closed State, not an Open State. Battlefields only become uncontrolled during an Open State, so you retain control until the Deathknell resolves and you can play a unit to that battlefield.

Sequence:

  • Temporary triggers at the start of your Beginning Phase, creating a chain
  • Temporary resolves, issuing a Kill instruction
  • Deathknell triggers and is added to the chain as a pending item
  • The unit moves to the trash and cleanup occurs
  • The battlefield does not become uncontrolled because the game is in a Closed State (pending item on chain)
  • Deathknell resolves, allowing you to play a unit to the battlefield
  • You retain control and can Hold and Score

Nuances:

  • Rule 323.6 only causes battlefields to become uncontrolled during an Open State (no chain exists)
  • A Neutral Closed state exists when there is no Showdown or Combat but a chain does exist
  • Pending items are on the chain, preventing the Open State condition
Comments (0)

No comments yet.

Log in to comment.

Open Proposals (0)

No pending proposals.

Log in to propose edits.