Can I play Hard Bargain even with nothing on the stack?
verified
FAQ #9898·April 30, 2026·Asked before Vendetta
Answer
No, you cannot play Hard Bargain if there is nothing on the chain.
According to the rules of the game:
- Targeting Requirements: Hard Bargain requires a target ("Counter a spell..."). To play a card, you must be able to choose a valid target at the time you place the spell on the chain. If there are no spells on the chain, there are no valid targets for Hard Bargain.
- Playing Cards: Rule 358.1 requires that you check that all chosen targets are legal when you play a card. If you cannot choose a legal target, the action of playing that card is illegal and will be cancelled (Rule 358.4).
While Hard Bargain has the [Reaction] keyword—allowing it to be played at times other than just when it's your main phase—it still requires a legal target to be played. Since a "spell" must be on the chain to be a target, an empty chain means there is nothing to target, and therefore you cannot play Hard Bargain.
Does this answer look correct?
0
Comments (0)
No comments yet.
Log in to comment.
Open Proposals (0)
No pending proposals.
Log in to propose edits.