Can you defy square up at repeat?

verified
FAQ #9994·May 2, 2026·Asked before Vendetta
Answer

You can use Defy to counter Square Up.

Analysis of the Interaction

  1. Defy's Targeting Requirements: Defy can only counter a spell that costs no more than 4 Energy and no more than 1 Power.
  2. Square Up's Cost: Square Up has a printed cost of 4 Energy and no Power cost. Because it meets these requirements (4 Energy ≤ 4 Energy and 0 Power ≤ 1 Power), it is a valid target for Defy.
  3. The Role of Repeat: The Repeat keyword functions as an additional cost paid when the spell is played. Paying the Repeat cost does not create a second spell, nor does it change the base cost of the original spell. When you target a "Repeated" spell with Defy, you are countering the single spell object on the chain, including both the initial and repeated effects.

Timing and Resolution

  • You must decide to pay the Repeat cost before the spell is finalized onto the chain.
  • Once the spell is on the chain, it can be targeted by Defy.
  • If Defy is played successfully, the entire spell (including the repeated effect) is countered and moves to the trash per . You cannot pay the Repeat cost after the spell has been countered.

Note: I could not fully verify this ruling against the retrieved rules.

Does this answer look correct?

0
Comments (0)

No comments yet.

Log in to comment.

Open Proposals (0)

No pending proposals.

Log in to propose edits.