Does Charm moving a unit to a battlefield where there is an enemy unit trigger Surprise Defender for the unit that is moved?
No, moving an enemy unit with Charm does not make it a "surprise defender."
Here is the breakdown of why this interaction functions differently than a "surprise defense":
1. The Definitions
- Surprise Defense: This is a tactical maneuver (typically performed by a player on their own turn or in reaction) where a player uses an effect to move their own unit into a battlefield where an opponent's unit is already attacking, designating themselves as the defender.
- Charm: This effect moves an enemy unit. According to RiftJudge FAQ #7385 and #7275, when you use Charm to move an enemy unit to a battlefield you control, that moved unit becomes the attacker. You (the controller of the battlefield) are the defender.
2. Why it isn't a "Surprise Defender"
"Surprise defender" is a term specifically used when you voluntarily move your own units to engage in combat on a battlefield where you were not previously present. Because Charm forces an enemy unit to move, it essentially "drags" them into a showdown where they are the aggressor, not a defender reacting to an attack.
Summary of the Flow
- You play Charm to move an enemy unit to a battlefield you occupy.
- A showdown is forced (if the battlefield becomes contested).
- The moved unit is designated as the Attacker.
- You are designated as the Defender.
Because the unit moved by Charm becomes the Attacker, it cannot be a "surprise defender." It is simply the attacking unit for that showdown.