When casting Icathian Rain against a unit with Deflect, do you pay the Deflect cost once or for each time you target that unit?

Ruling: You must pay the Deflect cost for each time you target a unit with Deflect, even if you target the same unit multiple times. Since Icathian Rain targets 6 times, you may need to pay Deflect up to 6 times.

Sequence:

  • Choose all 6 targets for Icathian Rain (you can target the same unit multiple times)
  • Pay the Deflect cost for each target that has Deflect
  • Opponent has opportunity to respond with reactions
  • Spell resolves and all 6 instances of damage happen

Nuances:

  • You pay Deflect costs before the spell can be countered by effects like Windwall
  • Opponents can play reactions after you choose targets but before the spell resolves
  • All 6 damage instances happen at resolution; you cannot use reactions between individual shots