During a showdown, when attack and defend triggers go on the chain, do they resolve separately or together, and which resolves first?
Ruling: When combat starts, all "when I attack" and "when I defend" triggers enter the chain together, with the attacking player's triggers added first. Chains resolve backwards (last in, first out), so the defending player's triggers resolve first.
Sequence:
- Combat starts
- Attacking player's "when I attack" triggers are added to the chain first
- Defending player's "when I defend" triggers are added to the chain second
- Chain resolves backwards: defending player's triggers resolve first, then attacking player's triggers
Nuances:
- The key distinction is that triggers from the defending player resolve first, not just "when I defend" triggers specifically. For example, triggers like "when enemy attacks" also resolve first because they belong to the defending player.
- Passive abilities like Shield are always active when defending and don't use the chain.