When two Akshans are played to steal gear from each other and then both die, who controls the gear?

Ruling: Controller is decided in the first layer using dependencies and timestamps. When control-change effects stop applying due to their sources leaving play, the gear returns to its original controller if no other control effects remain active.

Sequence:

  • Player A plays Akshan, creating a "change controller to Player A" effect on Player B's gear
  • Player B plays Akshan, creating a "change controller to Player B" effect that depends on and overrides Player A's effect due to timestamp order
  • If Player A's Akshan dies first, their control effect stops applying, but Player B's effect continues, so Player B controls the gear
  • If Player B's Akshan then dies, their control effect stops applying
  • With no control-change effects remaining, the gear returns to its original controller (Player B)

Nuances:

  • Control-change effects don't "take back" gear when they stop; they simply stop applying
  • When multiple control effects apply to the same object, they are applied in timestamp order, with later effects overriding earlier ones
  • The gear doesn't "bounce" between controllers when effects end; it simply resolves to whoever controls it after recalculating remaining effects
  • Layers are recalculated when an Akshan dies