Can Action-speed spells like Grand Strategem be used in response to "When I Attack" triggers like Anivia's?

Ruling: No, Action-speed spells cannot be used in response to "When I Attack" triggers during the initial chain of a showdown because the initial chain is closed and Action-speed spells can only be used in open chains.

Sequence:

  • When I Attack triggers automatically start the initial chain in a showdown
  • The initial chain must resolve first
  • After the initial chain resolves, the chain becomes open and Action-speed spells can be used
  • As the attacker, the opponent gets the first opportunity to use a spell after the initial chain

Nuances:

  • Reaction-speed spells can be used to react to "When I Attack" triggers when you gain priority
  • Adding abilities and permanents being played give no priority