Does an attached equipment with Temporary still get killed? (e.g., an attached Long Sword gets targeted by Fading Memories)

Ruling: No, an attached equipment with Temporary does NOT get killed while attached. Temporary is part of the equipment's Rules Text, which becomes Inactive while attached, preventing it from triggering.

Sequence:

  • Fading Memories gives the attached Long Sword Temporary
  • While attached, the Long Sword's Rules Text (including Temporary) is Inactive
  • Temporary cannot trigger while Inactive
  • If the equipment later becomes detached, its Rules Text becomes Active again
  • Temporary will then trigger at the start of the next Beginning Phase

Nuances:

  • Rules Text vs Effect Text is critical: Rules Text becomes Inactive when attached, Effect Text becomes Active when attached
  • This applies to all Rules Text abilities on equipment (Equip, Temporary, etc.), not just Temporary
  • The equipment must become detached before Temporary can trigger