If my unit with Temporary dies during my Beginning Phase and triggers a Deathknell ability, can I play a unit from Deathknell to the now-empty battlefield before it becomes uncontrolled?
Ruling: Yes. When Temporary triggers during your Beginning Phase, the Deathknell ability is added to the chain as a pending item before the unit moves to the trash. Because a pending item exists on the chain, the game is in a Closed State, not an Open State. Battlefields only become uncontrolled during an Open State, so you retain control until the Deathknell resolves and you can play a unit to that battlefield.
Sequence:
- Temporary triggers at the start of your Beginning Phase, creating a chain
- Temporary resolves, issuing a Kill instruction
- Deathknell triggers and is added to the chain as a pending item
- The unit moves to the trash and cleanup occurs
- The battlefield does not become uncontrolled because the game is in a Closed State (pending item on chain)
- Deathknell resolves, allowing you to play a unit to the battlefield
- You retain control and can Hold and Score
Nuances:
- Rule 323.6 only causes battlefields to become uncontrolled during an Open State (no chain exists)
- A Neutral Closed state exists when there is no Showdown or Combat but a chain does exist
- Pending items are on the chain, preventing the Open State condition