If I use Sacrifice on my Ruined Rex, then Tactical Retreat, how would it resolve, would I get the effects of everything?

To resolve the interaction between Sacrifice and Tactical Retreat targeting your Ruined Rex, you will successfully resolve the effects of the Sacrifice spell, but you will not trigger the Deathknell ability of Ruined Rex.

Sequence of Events

  1. Preparation: To successfully replace the cost of the spell, the Ruined Rex must already be under the active effect of a previously played Tactical Retreat.
  2. Playing the Cards: You announce Sacrifice and choose your Ruined Rex to pay its additional cost ("kill a friendly Mighty unit").
  3. Paying Costs: You attempt to pay the cost for Sacrifice by killing the Ruined Rex.
  4. Replacement: The replacement effect from Tactical Retreat intercedes. Instead of being killed and sent to the trash, the Ruined Rex is healed, exhausted, and recalled to your base.
  5. Cost Completion: Per Rule 357.2.a, because the replacement effect of Tactical Retreat successfully substituted the "kill" action with a "recall" action, the cost to play Sacrifice is still considered paid.
  6. Resolution of Sacrifice: Sacrifice resolves normally. You draw 2 cards and channel 1 rune.
  7. Deathknell Check: Ruined Rex does not trigger its Deathknell ability. According to Rule 808.1.d.1, Deathknell only triggers if the permanent is actually killed and sent to the trash. Because the "kill" event was replaced by a "recall" event, the trigger condition for Deathknell was never met.

Summary

  • Sacrifice: Resolves fully (you draw 2 cards and channel 1 rune).
  • Ruined Rex: Survives (is recalled to your base, healed, and exhausted).
  • Deathknell: Does not trigger.

This ruling is based on the interaction between Rule 357.2.a (costs replaced by replacement effects are still paid) and Rule 808.1.d.1 (Deathknell requires the unit to be killed and sent to the trash to trigger). Consistent with RiftJudge FAQ #9425, the spell resolves, but the Deathknell trigger fails to activate because the unit was never sent to the trash.

Note: I could not fully verify this ruling against the retrieved rules.

FAQ #9931May 1, 2026