0
Player 1 plays a spell that reads "Deal 4 to a unit at a battlefield. Discard 1. Draw 1. Move a friendly Unit from its base to a battlefield." Player 2 plays a spell that, before the resolution of that spell, moves the unit that was meant to be dealt 4 damage to its base. Given that Player 1 has no cards in hand, what will happen when Player 1's spell resolves?
unverified
Answer
Sign in as an arbiter with more than 50 reputation to verify answers. Learn more →
When Player 1's spell resolves, it will continue to resolve as much as possible despite the initial target becoming illegal. Here is the breakdown of what happens:
Sequence of Events
- Spell Finalization: Player 1 plays the spell targeting an enemy unit at a battlefield. The spell goes on the chain.
- Reaction: Player 2 plays a spell moving the targeted unit from the battlefield to their base.
- Chain Resolution (LIFO):
- Player 2's spell resolves, moving the unit to their base.
- Player 1's spell begins to resolve.
Resolution of Player 1's Spell
According to Core Rules Rule 359.3.e.1 and Rule 359.3.e.5, a spell resolves even if some of its targets are illegal, and instructions related to illegal targets are ignored.
- "Deal 4 to a unit at a battlefield": The target unit is no longer at a battlefield. It is an illegal target, so this instruction is ignored. No damage is dealt.
- "Discard 1": Player 1 has no cards in hand. Per Core Rules Rule 422.4, if instructed to discard more cards than they have, the instruction is ignored.
- "Draw 1": As per Core Rules Rule 359.3.e.11 (and the precedent in RiftJudge FAQ #3134), if one instruction in a spell is ignored or cannot be followed, the spell continues to resolve the remaining instructions. Player 1 draws 1 card.
- "Move a friendly Unit from its base to a battlefield": Player 1 may now choose a friendly unit at their base and move it to a battlefield, provided there is a legal destination (e.g., the battlefield is not at its unit capacity limit).
Summary: The spell will deal no damage, Player 1 will discard nothing, Player 1 will draw 1 card, and Player 1 will then perform the move if they have a legal unit and destination.
References
Suggested answer — derived from the references below
Rules
Related FAQs
Comments (0)
No comments yet.
Log in to comment.
Open Proposals (0)
No pending proposals.
Log in to propose edits.